Know exactly whether an Airbnb deal is worth your money in under 60 seconds. Plug in the numbers, get the verdict.
I don't buy STRs based on hope. Before I put in an offer, I pull actual revenue data from AirDNA or Rabbu for comparable properties within a 2-mile radius. I look at their average daily rate, occupancy rate, and revenue per available night. If the comps can't support the revenue I need to make the deal work, I walk. No amount of great photography or clever pricing can fix a market that doesn't have demand. I've owned over 20 Airbnbs — scaled down to 5 top performers for maximum ROI. Every single one was validated with real comp data first.
Break-even occupancy is the occupancy rate at which your revenue exactly covers all expenses including the mortgage. If your break-even is 70%, that means you have almost no margin for slow seasons, unexpected repairs, or market dips. I want my break-even occupancy below 50% on every property. That way, even in the worst months of the year, I'm still making money or at least breaking even. My South Carolina properties have break-even around 35-40% because the operating costs are low relative to the nightly rate. That's the sweet spot.
STRs aren't passive. They require more management than long-term rentals even with automation tools like Hospitable and Turno. So the returns need to be higher to justify the work. I target 15%+ cash-on-cash on my STRs. If I can only get 6% on a short-term rental, I'd rather buy a long-term rental that's actually passive for 8%. The extra revenue has to be worth the extra effort of guest communication, cleaning turnovers, restocking supplies, handling reviews, and dynamic pricing management. Tools help, but it's still a business.
The biggest mistake new STR investors make is underwriting based on summer rates or peak season occupancy. My Running Springs cabin near Big Bear crushes it in winter and summer but has shoulder seasons in spring and fall. If I'd underwritten to peak, I'd be panicking during slow months. I always underwrite to the 12-month average, then stress test with the worst 3 months isolated. If the property can survive January, February, and the slowest month in your market without bleeding cash, it's a solid buy. Seasonality is predictable if you plan for it.
I've seen investors buy a property, furnish it, list it, and then find out the city banned short-term rentals or requires a permit with a 2-year waitlist. This is the fastest way to turn a great deal into a disaster. Before I even run the numbers, I research: Does the city allow STRs? Is a permit required? Are there caps on permits? Are there HOA restrictions? What's the political climate — is the city council trying to restrict STRs? I manage properties in Running Springs, Tahoe, and South Carolina. Each has different rules. Knowing the regulations isn't optional — it's step one.
I share deal breakdowns, market analysis, revenue reports, and the exact strategies I use to run my Airbnb portfolio remotely from California. 20+ properties owned, scaled to 5 top performers.
Follow STR Intelligence on Instagram